Your Roofing Options Pros and Cons

Your Roofing Options Pros and Cons

Choosing the right type of roofing is a big part of having a new home built, so you need to look at all of the pros and cons of the different types of roofing that are out there today. By weighing them all against each other, you can pick the one that works best for your home and your budget. Remember that everyone has different needs and desires. You need to find the option that works for you, not the one that most people use or the one that your roofing company suggests. Take the time to figure this out before building begins.

Traditional Tar Paper and Shingles

One of the most common types of roofs that you will find is one that is covered in tar paper a heavy, back paper that comes in rolls and then shingles. These shingles are about half a metre long, and they are installed by putting them down, one at a time, and nailing them on so that the sides overlap. The advantage of this is that you get a great-looking roof that is waterproof and dependable. The cons are that this is very labour intensive, so it can get rather costly, and that damage to just a few shingles can cause a breach in the roof, allowing water to get in even though most of the roof is fine.

Cement Shingles

A new roofing option that has come on the market lately is the cement shingle. In many ways, this is just the same as the ones listed above, but they are made out of cement fibres. This means that they are incredibly strong and durable; some of them boast twice the lifespan of normal shingles. The upside here is that they will not be damaged that easily and that you may not have to replace the roof for 20 years or more. The downside is that these are very heavy, so they are even more labour intensive, and the whole project can get costly in a hurry.

Steel and Sheet Metal

If you want to stay away from shingles, you may want to consider sheet metal instead. Large pieces of metal about the size of drywall will be used. They can be set next to each other, so that they overlap on the edges, but this overlapping can be done far less often than it would with shingles since the pieces are so much larger. This helps to make the job shorter. You can often have sheet metal put down in just one day, whereas shingles will take a few days or a week. The faster the job can be done, the less it costs.

Another advantage to this type of roofing is that it is going to last you for a long time. Just paint it to make it waterproof, and it will not even rust. It is incredibly durable. While shingles can be ripped off of the roof one at a time, sheet metal is going to stay in place. The only cons to using it are the fact that it can rust through paint and tar can cure that easily and the way that it looks. If you do not want this modern style, it may not give your home the appearance that you are after.

Wood Shingles

Finally, a less common option is to use wood shingles. These are made from pieces of wood that are all cut to the same size this is usually done with an axe, though it can be done with a machine. They are then put on just like any other shingles. They have a terrific historic appearance, but they are not that practical. They tend to rot without constant upkeep and care. They are very labour intensive when they are being installed, so they cost a lot. The materials themselves can also be expensive, especially when you factor in that some will need to be replaced every few years.

Making Your Selection

To find the right type of roofing, you need to decide what is important to you. If price is no issue and you care only about the looks of the home, check out wood shingles. If you want a traditional style that blends in with the homes around you, try standard shingles. If you are looking for something cost-effective, durable, and easy to install, your best bet is sheet metal. They will all work, but some options might be better for your project than others.


Leave a Reply