Asphalt Shingles v Roofing in Warm to Moderate Climates Select Your Roof

Asphalt Shingles v Roofing in Warm to Moderate Climates Select Your Roof

Depending on the climate you live in, there are several choices for roofing materials. Asphalt shingles are by far the most popular choice, anywhere. Some homeowners, however, prefer tile, which comes in several shapes manufactured in concrete or clay. There are still strong followers of wood roofing materials such as cedar shakes and slate roofing in some higher end structures with traditional style. Metal roofing is also currently enjoying a good run in popularity.

In warmer to moderate climates, homeowners mostly find themselves comparing asphalt shingles to tile roofing. When theyre ready for a residential roof replacement or involved in a new construction project, pros and cons related to each of these two materials are often evaluated, depending on the particular home style, age and location.

Well-suited for warmer climates, clay or cement roofing tiles are a favorite choice for homes of Spanish design, or traditional Southwest or Florida style houses with stucco. Homeowners who choose these materials usually notice a cooler attic because these tiles do not attract and absorb the heat like asphalt. Theyre usually lighter in color as well, making them naturally cooler.

Having a tile roof can also increase a homes value, simply because the roof materials and labor cost more, and some tile companies guarantee the material for up to 50 years. But before you select tile as your material of choice, its important to be aware of a few disadvantages.

First, the additional value to the home doesnt come without a cost. An asphalt roof of $10,000 in labor and materials might cost anywhere from $18,000 to $20,000, or more, for a tile roof on the same house. For some, the decision will be made based only on cost of the material, especially in a re-roof project toward the less expensive solution.

The more aggressive cost of tile doesnt end with cost of installation. Even though tile roofs may come with longer warranties, its common for there to be problems with breakage. Storms or falling debris can cause cracks in the tiles or cause them to blow or fall off altogether. The cost of replacement, the regular need to wash the roof (1-2 years) and the periodic painting which may be required to keep the tile looking as good as the rest of the home, all contribute to a higher overall life-cycle cost of ownership which is more maintenance heavy.

While cost is always frequently a factor in selecting an asphalt shingle roof, there are plenty of other reasons why asphalt shingles are the most popular residential roofing material in North America.

Asphalt Shingles v Roofing in Warm to Moderate Climates Select Your Roof

For asphalt roofing shingles, materials and installation are both less expensive. Tile installation is more time consuming and requires additional steps so the cost of labor is higher. And while tile might keep a home cooler, they are also more prone to leaks when the tiles begin to weaken or loosen with age. Asphalt roofing provides several redundant seals, from underlayment to overlap. And when laminated shingles are used, asphalt shingles are much less at risk for storm damages.

Certainly any type of roof is at risk in a hurricane, but tile roofs actually lend themselves to more structural damages from high winds and flying tiles. Asphalt roofing hurricane damage will be more restricted to simply the roofing material, decking, etc. As to roof temperature from asphalt, adequate ventilation can keep the temperature of asphalt shingles fully reasonable, even in warmer climates.

Perhaps the biggest plus for asphalt roofing is how maintenance free it remains over time. If an asphalt roof is installed correctly, it can easily be set it and forget it for 20, 30 or even 40 years. While some asphalt shingle roofs still require cleaning due to dirty streaks and stains from algae growth, even this can be prevented with an algae resistant roof made with copper granule content.

Asphalt shingles come in many styles and colors as well. When selected carefully, asphalt shingles add simple elegance to a home, and remain attractive and protective for many years. If they do need to be serviced or replaced, its sometimes simple to put in a repair patch and blend them in without much difficulty, making asphalt roofing shingles a practical choice for optimum performance and maintenance on a residential roof.


Leave a Reply